Prison Fellowship

  • DONATE
    • One-Time
    • Monthly
    • Angel Tree
    • Other Ways to Give
  • GET INVOLVED
    • All Options
    • Subscribe
    • Angel Tree Christmas
    • Start a Fundraiser
    • Pray With Us
    • Justice Action Center
    • Share on Social
  • STORIES
    • Stories
    • Blog
    • Videos
    • The Restoration Series [Videos]
  • WHAT WE DO
    • Why Help Prisoners?
    • What We Do
    • In-Prison
      • Prison Fellowship Academy
      • In-Prison Programs
      • Hope Events
      • Inside Journal
      • Women’s Ministry
      • Create: New Beginnings
    • Angel Tree
      • Register your church or group for Angel Tree
      • Prison Fellowship Angel Tree
      • Angel Tree Christmas
      • Angel Tree Camping
      • Angel Tree Sports Camp
    • Justice Reform
      • Justice Reform
      • Second Chance Month
      • News & Updates
      • Sign the Justice Declaration
      • Get a Copy of Outrageous Justice
    • Warden Exchange
    • Church Partners
    • Corporate Partnerships
    • Preparing Prisoners for Reentry
    • Research and Evaluation
      • Good Citizenship Model™
  • RESOURCES
    • Subscribe to Our Email
    • Support for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Resources for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Coping with Incarceration
      • Resources for Prisoners
      • Resources for Children of Prisoners
      • Supporting Successful Prisoner Reentry
      • Subscribe To The Hope Connection
    • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • In-Prison Ministry
      • Reentry Ministry
      • Family Ministry
      • Justice Reform
      • Mentoring Ministry
    • Resources for Angel Tree Coordinators
    • Resources for Chaplains
    • Resources for D.O.C.
    • Justice Reform Resources
    • Share on Social
    • For Media Outlets
  • ABOUT US
    • Leadership
    • Chuck Colson
      • About Chuck Colson
      • The Charles Colson Hope Awards
    • Our Beliefs
    • Financials
      • Financials
      • 2022 Annual Report
    • Employment
    • Contact Us
    • In The News

Supreme Court Demands End to Prison Overcrowding

June 9, 2011 by Pat Nolan

The U.S. Supreme Court has decided that California’s prisons are so overstressed, they are unconstitutionally holding prisoners without providing appropriate medical and mental health care.

Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing for the majority in Brown v. Plata, notes that, “As many as 54 prisoners may share a single toilet.” And suicides average one a week, he says. The Court also cited a lower court’s finding that a prisoner dies unnecessarily every six to seven days.

This is very disturbing. Even one of the dissenting votes, Justice Samuel Alito, acknowledged “particular prisoners received shockingly deficient medical care,” though he ended up opposing the Court’s final decision.

WHO IS RESPONSIBLE?

When the government takes someone into its custody, it also takes on the responsibility of providing medical care. To deprive prisoners of adequate medical care is indeed “cruel and unusual punishment,” in violation of the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution. It means that a prisoner serving just months for a low-level crime might die from lack of proper medical attention, turning a short sentence into a sentence of death.

Whether or not the courts are the appropriate place to establish prison policy, it is undeniable that the political system in California has failed in its responsibility to manage prisons. One of the original lawsuits complaining of unconstitutional conditions was filed 21 years ago! And the legislature and a succession of governors did nothing to address the appalling conditions in California’s prisons for all those years.

These conditions are not the fault of prison officials. They don’t choose who to hold in prison. They take the prisoners sentenced under state law, and try to house them as best as possible with the dollars given them in the budget. The fault lies at the feet of politicians who have tried to have it both ways—adding years to sentences to appear tough on crime, but not appropriating the money needed to build prisons to hold the extra prisoners those policies have locked up.

However, laying blame doesn’t help. We now have to find ways to help the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDRC) comply with the Court’s order without putting the public at risk. No one wants the state to release prisoners who are unprepared to abide by the law when they are released. The problem is that California and most other states do not have the money to do this pre-release preparation.

A FAITH-FILLED RESPONSE

Fortunately, faith-based and community groups have been stepping up to do this work at no cost to the government!

In fact, when the Court released its opinion, I was at an Out4Life conference Prison Fellowship® sponsored in San Diego, at which hundreds of leaders from faith-based and community groups met with corrections officials and law enforcement leaders to build local coalitions to provide reentry services both before and after release. Inside prisons, volunteers will work with prisoners on preparing a life plan, writing a résumé, arranging for housing, repairing relationships with family members, and other skills necessary to make a successful transition to the free world.

After prison, these volunteer coalitions will coordinate job placement, housing, drug treatment, and medical care, and then match prisoners with a mentor to support them with accountability and practical advice. In short, these volunteers will help them become good neighbors.

This combination of accountability and assistance has been proven effective at changing the lives of prisoners and lowering recidivism. That means safer communities, fewer victims, and lower costs for the state taxpayers.

SAFER COMMUNITIES

This is a vision that Prison Fellowship founder Chuck Colson and I laid out in “Prescription for Safer Communities,” which was published by the Notre Dame Law School. I think you will find that given this Court decision—and the legislative successes Justice Fellowship®, the justice reform arm of Prison Fellowship, has experienced in the past several years—what we wrote is even more relevant now than when we wrote it.

My hat is off to Matt Cate, California’s Secretary of Corrections and Rehabilitation. Long before the Court’s order, Matt was working with Prison Fellowship to plan this Out4Life conference. His far-sighted leadership will help bring volunteers inside prisons to do the work the state just cannot afford to do on its own. And these volunteers will provide something that government employees cannot: love.

Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. said, “To change someone, you must first love them, and they must know that you love them.”

You can read more about the importance of Out4Life and how California’s CDCR, Prison Fellowship, and the other groups will work to dramatically increase the programs available for prisoners in an op-ed Matt and I wrote. Thank you, Mr. Cate, for recognizing that faith-based and community groups can work in partnership with you and your department to change prisoners’ lives and make our communities safer. You are a fine example of a courageous public servant.

Filed Under: Advocacy & Reentry, Prison & Prisoners, Uncategorized Tagged With: California, Eighth Ammendment, supreme court

SELECT A TOPIC

  • Advocacy & Reentry
  • Angel Tree
  • Families of Prisoners
  • Feature Stories
  • From the CEO
  • Hope Events
  • Inside Journal
  • Press Releases
  • Prison & Prisoners
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Prison Fellowship International
  • Prison Fellowship News & Updates
  • Reentry
  • Second Chance Month
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Warden Exchange

MOST POPULAR

Prison Fellowship’s Statement on the Federal Prison Oversight Act

June 21, 2023

Prison Fellowship’s Statement on President Biden’s Announcement of Second Chance Month Initiatives

May 1, 2023

‘The Chosen’ Soon Available to Tens of Thousands of Incarcerated by Floodlight Streaming Service

May 1, 2023

LATEST VIDEOS

WATCH ALL VIDEOS

JOIN OUR ONLINE COMMUNITY

FACEBOOK
TWITTER
INSTAGRAM
YOUTUBE
LINKEDIN
PF®
PFM®

RECOMMENDED LINKS

  • Ways to Donate
  • Inspirational Stories
  • Angel Tree Program
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Justice Reform

RESOURCES

  • For Families & Friends of Prisoners
  • For Churches & Angel Tree Volunteers
  • For Media Outlets
  • Warden Exchange

JOIN RESTORATION PARTNERS AND WITNESS GOD RESTORE LIVES

Restoration Partners give monthly to bring life-changing prison ministry programs to incarcerated men and women across the country.

 

JOIN NOW
  • CONTACT US
  • EMPLOYMENT
  • PRIVACY
  • FINANCIALS
© 2023 PRISON FELLOWSHIP®

Angel Tree®, Angel Tree Camping®, Angel Tree Sports ClinicTM, Angel Tree Sports CampsTM, and Warden Exchange® are programs of Prison Fellowship®.