Prison Fellowship

  • DONATE
    • One-Time
    • Monthly
    • Angel Tree
    • Other Ways to Give
  • GET INVOLVED
    • Volunteer
    • Subscribe
    • Angel Tree Christmas
    • Start a Fundraiser
    • Pray With Us
    • Justice Action Center
    • Share on Social
  • STORIES
    • Stories
    • Blog
    • Videos
    • The Restoration Series [Videos]
  • WHAT WE DO
    • Why Help Prisoners?
    • What We Do
    • In-Prison
      • Prison Fellowship Academy
      • In-Prison Programs
      • Hope Events
      • Inside Journal
      • Women’s Ministry
      • Create: New Beginnings
    • Angel Tree
      • Register your church or group for Angel Tree
      • Prison Fellowship Angel Tree
      • Angel Tree Christmas
      • Angel Tree Camping
      • Angel Tree Sports Camps
    • Justice Reform
      • Justice Reform
      • Second Chance Month
      • Sign the Justice Declaration
      • Get a Copy of Outrageous Justice
    • Warden Exchange
    • Church Partners
    • Corporate Partnerships
    • Preparing Prisoners for Reentry
  • RESOURCES
    • Subscribe to Our Email
    • Support for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Resources for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Coping with Incarceration
      • Resources for Prisoners
      • Resources for Children of Prisoners
      • Supporting Successful Prisoner Reentry
    • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • In-Prison Ministry
      • Reentry Ministry
      • Family Ministry
      • Justice Reform
      • Mentoring Ministry
    • Resources for Angel Tree Coordinators
    • Resources for Chaplains
    • Resources for D.O.C.
    • Justice Reform Resources
    • Share on Social
    • For Media Outlets
  • ABOUT US
    • Leadership
    • Chuck Colson
      • About Chuck Colson
      • The Charles Colson Hope Awards
    • Our Beliefs
    • Financials
      • Financials
      • 2022 Annual Report
    • Employment
    • Contact Us
    • In The News

Why We Should Put Probation on Trial

January 6, 2015 by Elisabeth Boehm

“An ineffective probation system can result in further criminal acts and the imprisonment of those same offenders before they complete their terms.”

Justice Fellowship’s latest report, Incentives in State Probation Systems: Relation to Structure and Practices, reveals why it’s a good idea to examine our probation systems.

The report examines some of the incentives that impact how certain states run their probation systems and highlights two factors that contribute to the effectiveness of those systems.

The first factor that could be working against probation effectiveness is this: probation agencies rarely publish the recidivism rates of former probationers.

If there’s any merit to the staying ‘what gets measured gets done,’ the problem with agencies failing to measure and publish the success rate of their former probationers is immediately obvious. If the goal of probation is to direct men and women away from crime, facilitating their transformation into engaged and contributing citizens, then agencies should be rewarded and commended by legislatures and the public for each individual who completes probation and remains crime-free.

State probation agencies should publish their success rates, enabling citizens to be confident that the probation practices used in their states are working.

The second factor contributing to probation system effectiveness is management.

Probation systems are managed differently across the states. It is beneficial to evaluate which methods produce the best results because, as the report notes, “Poorly-administered probation is a waste of time and money and fails to reduce crime.”

There are three main ways that probation is administered.

  • The state department of corrections houses the probation agency.
  • State and local governments share the responsibility of managing the agency.
  • The courts run the agency.

In the first case, the report finds that states have an incentive to both over-use and underfund probation. In the second case, the state is pitted against the local governments, with both having an incentive to lower their costs by offloading offenders onto the other. According to the report, the third case creates the most beneficial incentives; probation agencies operated by the courts show greater emphasis on reforming offenders and reducing recidivism.

Why is this?

Courts have more independence, and judges tend to have long terms, and therefore longer outlooks, compared to top administrators in other government agencies. While court-run probation agencies tend to have better results, they achieve those results at a greater average cost, the report concludes.

Because probation can be a viable alternative to prison, structuring agencies in the judiciary and pushing them to measure and publish the success rate of former probationers seems to yield the best opportunity for success.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Justice Fellowship, Probation, recidivism, Success Rates

SELECT A TOPIC

  • Advocacy & Reentry
  • Angel Tree
  • Families of Prisoners
  • Feature Stories
  • From the CEO
  • Hope Events
  • Inside Journal
  • Press Releases
  • Prison & Prisoners
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Prison Fellowship International
  • Prison Fellowship News & Updates
  • Reentry
  • Second Chance Month
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Warden Exchange

MOST POPULAR

Prison Fellowship Responds to Inaction on Crack Cocaine Sentencing at Close of the 117th Congress

December 20, 2022

Criminal Justice Reform Achievements

December 16, 2022

Prison Fellowship Applauds Congressional Lawmakers for Passage of Law Enforcement De-escalation Training Act

December 15, 2022

LATEST VIDEOS

WATCH ALL VIDEOS

JOIN OUR ONLINE COMMUNITY

FACEBOOK
TWITTER
INSTAGRAM
YOUTUBE
LINKEDIN
PF®
PFM®

RECOMMENDED LINKS

  • Ways to Donate
  • Inspirational Stories
  • Angel Tree Program
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Justice Reform

RESOURCES

  • For Families & Friends of Prisoners
  • For Churches & Angel Tree Volunteers
  • For Media Outlets

JOIN RESTORATION PARTNERS AND WITNESS GOD RESTORE LIVES

Restoration Partners give monthly to bring life-changing prison ministry programs to incarcerated men and women across the country.

 

JOIN NOW
  • CONTACT US
  • EMPLOYMENT
  • PRIVACY
  • FINANCIALS
© 2023 PRISON FELLOWSHIP®

Angel Tree®, Angel Tree Camping®, Angel Tree Sports ClinicTM, Angel Tree Sports CampsTM, and Warden Exchange® are programs of Prison Fellowship®.