Prison Fellowship

  • DONATE
    • One-Time
    • Monthly
    • Angel Tree
    • Other Ways to Give
  • GET INVOLVED
    • Volunteer
    • Subscribe
    • Angel Tree Christmas
    • Start a Fundraiser
    • Pray With Us
    • Justice Action Center
    • Share on Social
  • STORIES
    • Stories
    • Blog
    • Videos
    • The Restoration Series [Videos]
  • WHAT WE DO
    • Why Help Prisoners?
    • What We Do
    • In-Prison
      • Prison Fellowship Academy
      • In-Prison Programs
      • Hope Events
      • Inside Journal
      • Women’s Ministry
      • Create: New Beginnings
    • Angel Tree
      • Register your church or group for Angel Tree
      • Prison Fellowship Angel Tree
      • Angel Tree Christmas
      • Angel Tree Camping
      • Angel Tree Sports Camps
    • Justice Reform
      • Justice Reform
      • Second Chance Month
      • News & Updates
      • Sign the Justice Declaration
      • Get a Copy of Outrageous Justice
    • Warden Exchange
    • Church Partners
    • Corporate Partnerships
    • Preparing Prisoners for Reentry
  • RESOURCES
    • Subscribe to Our Email
    • Support for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Resources for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Coping with Incarceration
      • Resources for Prisoners
      • Resources for Children of Prisoners
      • Supporting Successful Prisoner Reentry
    • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • In-Prison Ministry
      • Reentry Ministry
      • Family Ministry
      • Justice Reform
      • Mentoring Ministry
    • Resources for Angel Tree Coordinators
    • Resources for Chaplains
    • Resources for D.O.C.
    • Justice Reform Resources
    • Share on Social
    • For Media Outlets
  • ABOUT US
    • Leadership
    • Chuck Colson
      • About Chuck Colson
      • The Charles Colson Hope Awards
    • Our Beliefs
    • Financials
      • Financials
      • 2022 Annual Report
    • Employment
    • Contact Us
    • In The News

The Right to Defense Counsel

Issue Overview

The right to counsel is a constitutional right guaranteed to all citizens of the United States who are involved in criminal prosecutions. As written in the Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution, “In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right … to have the Assistance of Counsel for his defence [sic].”1 Subsequent decisions of the Supreme Court have highlighted the contours of the right to counsel, always emphasizing that this extends to protect those who are unable to afford the fees of a private attorney.2 The Court has also held that assistance of counsel must be effective.3 Since 1974, the U.S. Justice Department has issued standards to govern indigent defense.4 As a result, jurisdictions generally maintain up-to-date lists of court appointed attorneys who will serve as defense counsel to indigent individuals with criminal cases before the court.

The right to counsel applies at critical stages of a criminal case, including interrogation after arrest, line-ups and identification procedures, preliminary hearings, arraignments, and plea bargain negotiations.5 The right also applies after conviction in sentencing proceedings, appeals of right, and in certain probation and parole proceedings.6 The right to counsel also extends to some other proceedings not traditionally a part of a criminal case, where those proceedings may result in deprivation of liberty. These include hearings on the subject matter of mental competency and commitment, extradition, prison disciplinary proceedings, some family cases, juvenile status offense hearings, and cases of abuse and neglect.7

Access to effective counsel varies across jurisdictions, and caseloads often overwhelm the resources of court-appointed legal representatives. Despite the American Bar Association’s recommendation that no public defender manage more than 150 felony cases each year, attorneys in Miami Dade County had to serve in 700 cases annually.8In 17 states, counties are primarily responsible to fund indigent defense.9Limited availability of state and federal aid and discrepancies in county fiscal capacities contribute to risks of poorly funded and overworked defense attorneys.10 And, in the absence of a precise definition of effective counsel, state courts have been ill-equipped to intervene in case-specific instances of poor indigent counsel.11 However, systems in which full-time public defenders are hired and managed out of centralized state or local offices have proven more successful in reducing conviction rates, severity of sentences, and taxpayer costs than contracts with outside private attorneys or firms.12 Several state and local initiatives also show promise for improving the quality of legal representation. For example, mentoring and training programs from the District of Columbia’s Public Defender Service have been hailed as a model for promoting excellence and morale among new public defenders.13

Position

Prison Fellowship believes that a just process is an integral part of a successful, restorative criminal justice system. Ensuring access to effective counsel requires adequate attention and resources devoted to indigent defense services. To fully engage due process, each party must have the opportunity to be zealously represented in a court of law where they are presumed innocent until proved guilty. The assistance of an equipped attorney also allows for the maximum level of participation by the responsible party in court proceedings, including participation with full consideration of plea bargains, impact statements, and other key moments in preparation, trial, and settlement.

Jurisdictions should pursue excellence in their provision of indigent defense services, recognizing that inadequate provisions in this area have dramatic impacts on poor and marginalized people in our communities. In particular, 1while most racial groups require indigent defense services, data from state criminal cases shows that Black and Latino defendants are more likely to be assigned a public defender or assigned counsel compared to their white counterparts.14

All people, regardless of their access to wealth, their race, or their influence, should enjoy unburdened access to this primary right guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment. The right to counsel is, in the words of Chief Justice Roberts, “the most precious right a defendant has, because it is his attorney who will fight for the other rights the defendant enjoys.”15 By upholding this vital principle, our society maintains the truth of each person’s individual dignity and worth, upholds their potential for human flourishing, and ensures just process.

SOURCES

[1] PU.S. Const. amend. VI.

[2] Johnson v. Zerbst, 304 U.S. 458 (1938); Powell v. Alabama, 287 U.S. 45 (1938); Betts v. Brady, 837 U.S. 455 (1938); Gideon v. Wainwright, 372 U.S. 335 (1963); In re Gault, 387 U.S. 1 (1967); Argersinger v. Hamlin, 407 U.S. 25 (1972).

[3] Strickland v. Washington, 466 U.S. 668 (1984).

[4] National Institute of Justice, Overview of Indigent Defense, U.S. Department of Justice (2019), https://ojp.gov/indigentdefense/compendium.

[5] Miranda v. Arizona, 384 U.S. 436 (1966); Brewer v. Williams, 430 U.S. 387 (1977); United States v. Wade,  388 U.S. 218 (1967); Moore v. Illinois, 434 U.S. 220 (1977); Coleman v. Alabama, 399 U.S. 1 (1970); Hamilton v. Alabama, 368 U.S. 52 (1961); Brady v. United States, 397 U.S. 742 (1970); McMann v. Richardson, 397 U.S. 759 (1970).

[6] Townsend v. Burke, 334 U.S. 736 (1948); United States v. Tucker, 404 U.S. 443 (1972); Douglas v. California, 372 U.S. 353 (1963); Mempa v. Rhay, 389 U.S. 128 (1967).

[7] History of Right to Counsel, NLDA.org, https://www.nlada.org/About/About_HistoryDefender (last visited Dec. 18, 2015).

[8] Eve Brensike Primus, Defense Counsel and Public Defense, Arizona State University Sandra Day O’Connor School of Law Academy for Justice (2017), https://law.asu.edu/sites/default/files/pdf/academy_for_justice/6_Reforming-Criminal-Justice_Vol_3_Defense-Counsel-and-Public-Defense.pdf.

[9] Bryan Furst, A Fair Fight: Achieving Indigent Defense Resource Parity, Brennan Center for Justice (September 9, 2019), https://www.brennancenter.org/sites/default/files/2019-09/Report_A%20Fair%20Fight.pdf.

[10] Furst, supra note 9 at 9-10; Primus, supra note 8 at 125-126.

[11] Primus, supra note 8 at 125-126.

[12] Furst, supra note 9; James Anderson & Paul Heaton, How Much Difference Does a Lawyer Make? The Effect of Defense Counsel on Murder Outcomes, The Yale Law Journal (2012), https://www.yalelawjournal.org/pdf/1105_8izvsf8m.pdf; Office of the State Public Defender, State Public Defender’s Efficiency Report, Iowa Office of the State Public Defender (2007), https://www.legis.iowa.gov/docs/publications/DF/7519.pdf

[13] Eve Brensike Primus, Culture as a Structural Promise in Indigent Defense, Minnesota Law Review (2016), https://repository.law.umich.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2837&context=articles.

[14] Caroline Wolf Harlow, Defense Counsel in Criminal Cases, Bureau of Justice Statistics (2000), https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/dccc.pdf (finding that in state criminal cases “69 percent of white inmates reported they had lawyers appointed by the court, 77 percent of blacks and 73 percent of Hispanics had public defenders or assigned counsel”).

[15] Kaley v. United States, 571 US 320 (2014).

CONNECT WITH PRISON FELLOWSHIP

Sign up to receive our weekly eNewsletter, which highlights stories of transformed lives and second chances, as well as resources and information from around the ministry.

SIGNUP TODAY

PARTNER WITH US

Join our advocacy network by signing the Justice Declaration to receive news, event invites, and action alerts from the Prison Fellowship advocacy team about justice reform in your state and Congress.

JOIN NOW

JOIN OUR ONLINE COMMUNITY

FACEBOOK
TWITTER
INSTAGRAM
YOUTUBE
LINKEDIN
PF®
PFM®

RECOMMENDED LINKS

  • Ways to Donate
  • Inspirational Stories
  • Angel Tree Program
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Justice Reform

RESOURCES

  • For Families & Friends of Prisoners
  • For Churches & Angel Tree Volunteers
  • For Media Outlets
  • Warden Exchange

JOIN RESTORATION PARTNERS AND WITNESS GOD RESTORE LIVES

Restoration Partners give monthly to bring life-changing prison ministry programs to incarcerated men and women across the country.

 

JOIN NOW
  • CONTACT US
  • EMPLOYMENT
  • PRIVACY
  • FINANCIALS
© 2023 PRISON FELLOWSHIP®

Angel Tree®, Angel Tree Camping®, Angel Tree Sports ClinicTM, Angel Tree Sports CampsTM, and Warden Exchange® are programs of Prison Fellowship®.