Prison Fellowship

  • DONATE
    • One-Time
    • Monthly
    • Angel Tree
    • Other Ways to Give
  • GET INVOLVED
    • Volunteer
    • Subscribe
    • Angel Tree Christmas
    • Start a Fundraiser
    • Pray With Us
    • Justice Action Center
    • Share on Social
  • STORIES
    • Stories
    • Blog
    • Videos
    • The Restoration Series [Videos]
  • WHAT WE DO
    • Why Help Prisoners?
    • What We Do
    • In-Prison
      • Prison Fellowship Academy
      • In-Prison Programs
      • Hope Events
      • Inside Journal
      • Women’s Ministry
      • Create: New Beginnings
    • Angel Tree
      • Register your church or group for Angel Tree
      • Prison Fellowship Angel Tree
      • Angel Tree Christmas
      • Angel Tree Camping
      • Angel Tree Sports Camps
    • Justice Reform
      • Justice Reform
      • Second Chance Month
      • News & Updates
      • Sign the Justice Declaration
      • Get a Copy of Outrageous Justice
    • Warden Exchange
    • Church Partners
    • Corporate Partnerships
    • Preparing Prisoners for Reentry
  • RESOURCES
    • Subscribe to Our Email
    • Support for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Resources for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Coping with Incarceration
      • Resources for Prisoners
      • Resources for Children of Prisoners
      • Supporting Successful Prisoner Reentry
    • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • In-Prison Ministry
      • Reentry Ministry
      • Family Ministry
      • Justice Reform
      • Mentoring Ministry
    • Resources for Angel Tree Coordinators
    • Resources for Chaplains
    • Resources for D.O.C.
    • Justice Reform Resources
    • Share on Social
    • For Media Outlets
  • ABOUT US
    • Leadership
    • Chuck Colson
      • About Chuck Colson
      • The Charles Colson Hope Awards
    • Our Beliefs
    • Financials
      • Financials
      • 2022 Annual Report
    • Employment
    • Contact Us
    • In The News

Should We Change Penalties for Crack Cocaine Crimes? And Other Drug Disparity Questions Answered

April 7, 2021 by Heather Rice-Minus

Frequently Asked Questions About Drug Disparity

end the disparity

Powder cocaine has been available since the 19th century. In the 1980s, crack cocaine—made from powder cocaine, baking soda, and boiling water—appeared on American streets. Although both forms of cocaine are nearly identical chemically and have similar effects, Congress set vastly different penalties for the drugs. From 1986 to 2010, it took 100 times more powder cocaine than crack cocaine to trigger the same federal mandatory minimum sentences. While Congress reduced this "100:1" disparity in 2010, it remains at "18:1" today.

Prison Fellowship® and the criminal justice reform advocacy group FAMM have partnered to launch the #EndTheDisparity campaign fix this inconsistency in federal law, which has increased overincarceration, especially among Black Americans. Now, Congress is considering the Eliminating a Quantifiably Unjust Application of the Law (EQUAL) Act (not to be confused with the Equality Act), bipartisan legislation that addresses America’s current sentencing disparity for cocaine offenses.

But isn't crack cocaine more addictive than powder? Isn't crack cocaine linked to more violence? Why would we want less severe sentences for those convicted of crack cocaine crime? How exactly does this issue connect to race?

QUESTION: IS CRACK COCAINE MORE ADDICTIVE THAN POWDER?

ANSWER

Certain methods of cocaine administration can increase frequency of use and consequent addiction risks because of the user’s possible desire to repeat more immediate, shorter, and intense “highs.”

ANSWER: There is a common misconception that crack is more addictive than powder cocaine. In reality, neither is more addictive than the other. They are, as the United States Sentencing Commission points out, “both powerful stimulants, and both forms of cocaine cause identical effects.”

That said, there is evidence certain methods of cocaine administration can increase frequency of use and heighten related addiction risks. This is likely because of a person’s desire to repeat more immediate, shorter, and more intense “highs.” Methods like smoking—which is more easily and commonly done with crack cocaine—and injection—which is rare but more often associated with powder cocaine—can produce these experiences.

However, the method of cocaine use is just one risk factor among others in accounting for cocaine addiction: existing mental health challenges and marijuana, alcohol, and/or opioid dependencies are also key variables. Additionally, individuals who use crack cocaine more often live in marginalized communities with limited access to prevention and treatment for addiction compared to others grappling with substance abuse. Ultimately, precisely quantifying the difference in the method of use or many addiction risk factors to determine the appropriate punishment for crack cocaine compared to powder cocaine is next to impossible.

QUESTION: IS CRACK COCAINE MORE LINKED TO VIOLENCE THAN POWDER COCAINE?

ANSWER

ANSWER: Passing the EQUAL Act would not compromise community safety. Individuals resentenced under more proportional penalties for crack cocaine had nearly identical recidivism rates than those with longer sentences. More consistent penalties for crack cocaine in federal law since 2010 have not led to an increase in this drug’s use. More than 40 states combat substance abuse without treating crack cocaine and powder cocaine differently in their sentencing structures. In fact, we hope that savings in reducing overincarceration accrued from sentencing reforms like the EQUAL Act can be invested into community policing, solving violent crime, and other strategies that bring safety and prosperity to vulnerable communities.

QUESTION: SHOULD WE CHANGE PUNISHMENTS FOR CRACK COCAINE CRIMES?

ANSWER

Harsher sentences have been ineffective in deterring crack cocaine offenses and have instead contributed to overincarceration and racial imbalances.

ANSWER: We believe both powder and crack cocaine offenses demand accountability, including through incarceration where appropriate. We also believe punishments should be proportional, consistent with biblical values.

Given that crack and powder cocaine are two forms of the same drug, the same proportional punishments should apply to equivalent amounts of crack and powder cocaine. This change would still hold people accountable, but without the damage of unjustly long crack-related sentences, which undermine trust in the justice system and contribute to the breakdown of families and communities.

Inconsistent federal penalties for crack and powder cocaine are an ineffective tools for curbing drug crime. Harsher federal sentences for crack cocaine from 1986 have not reduced crack cocaine use or increased the price of crack cocaine. In fact, these penalties have mostly affected less significant actors in drug distribution chains—people who are often struggling themselves with addiction and who can often be easily substituted by criminal networks. The disparity has contributed to overincarceration and racial disparities in the justice system—all while failing to keep community safe.

QUESTION: DOESN'T CRACK COCAINE CAUSE VIOLENCE?

ANSWER

ANSWER: Crack cocaine use is not a predictor of violence. Differences between violent conduct among users of crack cocaine and powder cocaine, in fact, “were almost uniformly statistically nonsignificant” when key socioeconomic and health factors were considered.

The violence associated with crack cocaine in the 1980s when the federal disparity was enacted was not caused by the drug itself. Rather, this decade saw the abrupt expansion of drug markets in impoverished, predominantly Black communities and corresponding violent conflict between sellers.

In the 1990s, there was a dramatic reduction in urban violence as drug purchases were conducted privately away from volatile street markets, economic growth provided opportunity for at-risk youth, and law enforcement targeted illegal gun possession.

The recent homicide spike in American cities during COVID-19 requires bold policy remedies; however contemporary urban violence is less connected to violent conflict and instability within drug and crack cocaine markets.

Violent crime, whether independently or in connection to drug distribution, is a serious problem that demands accountability. We should pursue focused actions against violent conduct and not rely on indirect and disproportionate penalties that increase overincarceration and racial disparities in our justice system.

QUESTION: HOW DOES THE COCAINE SENTENCING DISPARITY CONNECT TO RACE?

ANSWER

‘The LORD detests dishonest scales, but accurate weights find favor with him.’
—Proverbs 11:1

ANSWER: We believe the current sentencing scheme for crack cocaine is disproportional for all Americans. At the same time, the current disparity in how federal law punishes crack cocaine compared to powder cocaine crimes has a particularly serious impact on Black Americans.

Why is this? Crack cocaine is more widely used in marginalized communities of color, which also experienced more punitive responses to crime and addiction. Because of this, Black Americans more sharply experience the costs of the sentencing disparity. In the years after Congress enacted the federal crack cocaine disparity, the average federal drug sentence for Black defendants was 49% higher than the average for white Americans. In 2019, 81% of defendants convicted of federal crack cocaine distribution were Black. These lengthy federal prison terms and their consequences—weakening family structure, limiting economic opportunity, and discouraging rehabilitation—are uniquely concentrated among Black Americans.

James J. Ackerman, president and CEO of Prison Fellowship, has stated,

The Bible tells us in Proverbs 11:1, God has no tolerance for dishonest scales, whether it’s in the marketplace or the justice system. We have seen the impact that injustice has had on communities. We believe as Christians that we are to act to correct injustices. The bipartisan introduction of the EQUAL Act in the House reflects the diverse and urgent momentum to finally end this glaring example of racial injustice.

Often, the dynamics of racial impact in the criminal justice system are complex and difficult to solve. Here we can take a concrete step to diminish injustice, and we need to do so.


ABOUT HEATHER RICE-MINUS

Heather Rice-Minus is the senior vice president of advocacy and church mobilization at Prison Fellowship.

FURTHER READING

  • Federal Crack Cocaine Disparity Myth-Buster
  • Evangelical Christians Must Take Action To Love Thy Neighbor
  • Matthew Charles and Ending Racial Inequity in the Justice System
  • FAMM and Prison Fellowship Launch #EndTheDisparity Campaign

RAISE YOUR VOICE!

As Christians, we are called to speak out against unjust sentencing. You can raise your voice by sending a letter your Congressperson and the president, urging them to end the disparity between how crack and powder cocaine are punished.

TAKE ACTION

DID YOU ENJOY THIS ARTICLE?

Make sure you don' t miss out on any of our helpful articles and incredible transformation stories! Sign up to receive our weekly newsletter, and you' ll get great content delivered directly to your inbox.

Your privacy is safe with us. We will never sell, trade, or share your personal information.

Filed Under: Advocacy & Reentry, Prison Fellowship News & Updates

SELECT A TOPIC

  • Advocacy & Reentry
  • Angel Tree
  • Families of Prisoners
  • Feature Stories
  • From the CEO
  • Hope Events
  • Inside Journal
  • Press Releases
  • Prison & Prisoners
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Prison Fellowship International
  • Prison Fellowship News & Updates
  • Reentry
  • Second Chance Month
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Warden Exchange

MOST POPULAR

Prison Fellowship Statement on Tyre Nichols

January 28, 2023

Prison Fellowship Responds to Inaction on Crack Cocaine Sentencing at Close of the 117th Congress

December 20, 2022

Criminal Justice Reform Achievements

December 16, 2022

LATEST VIDEOS

WATCH ALL VIDEOS

JOIN OUR ONLINE COMMUNITY

FACEBOOK
TWITTER
INSTAGRAM
YOUTUBE
LINKEDIN
PF®
PFM®

RECOMMENDED LINKS

  • Ways to Donate
  • Inspirational Stories
  • Angel Tree Program
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Justice Reform

RESOURCES

  • For Families & Friends of Prisoners
  • For Churches & Angel Tree Volunteers
  • For Media Outlets
  • Warden Exchange

JOIN RESTORATION PARTNERS AND WITNESS GOD RESTORE LIVES

Restoration Partners give monthly to bring life-changing prison ministry programs to incarcerated men and women across the country.

 

JOIN NOW
  • CONTACT US
  • EMPLOYMENT
  • PRIVACY
  • FINANCIALS
© 2023 PRISON FELLOWSHIP®

Angel Tree®, Angel Tree Camping®, Angel Tree Sports ClinicTM, Angel Tree Sports CampsTM, and Warden Exchange® are programs of Prison Fellowship®.