Prison Fellowship

  • DONATE
    • One-Time
    • Monthly
    • Angel Tree
    • Other Ways to Give
  • GET INVOLVED
    • Subscribe
    • Angel Tree Christmas
    • Start a Fundraiser
    • Pray With Us
    • Justice Action Center
    • Share on Social
  • STORIES
    • Stories
    • Blog
    • Videos
    • The Restoration Series [Videos]
  • WHAT WE DO
    • Why Help Prisoners?
    • What We Do
    • In-Prison
      • Prison Fellowship Academy
      • In-Prison Programs
      • Hope Events
      • Inside Journal
      • Women’s Ministry
      • Create: New Beginnings
    • Angel Tree
      • Register your church or group for Angel Tree
      • Prison Fellowship Angel Tree
      • Angel Tree Christmas
      • Angel Tree Camping
      • Angel Tree Sports Camp
    • Justice Reform
      • Justice Reform
      • Second Chance Month
      • News & Updates
      • Sign the Justice Declaration
      • Get a Copy of Outrageous Justice
    • Warden Exchange
    • Church Partners
    • Corporate Partnerships
    • Preparing Prisoners for Reentry
  • RESOURCES
    • Subscribe to Our Email
    • Support for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Resources for Friends and Family of Prisoners
      • Coping with Incarceration
      • Resources for Prisoners
      • Resources for Children of Prisoners
      • Supporting Successful Prisoner Reentry
    • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • Resources for Churches and Volunteers
      • In-Prison Ministry
      • Reentry Ministry
      • Family Ministry
      • Justice Reform
      • Mentoring Ministry
    • Resources for Angel Tree Coordinators
    • Resources for Chaplains
    • Resources for D.O.C.
    • Justice Reform Resources
    • Research and Evaluation Library
    • Share on Social
    • For Media Outlets
  • ABOUT US
    • Leadership
    • Chuck Colson
      • About Chuck Colson
      • The Charles Colson Hope Awards
    • Our Beliefs
    • Financials
      • Financials
      • 2022 Annual Report
    • Employment
    • Contact Us
    • In The News

In A Cell Until Proven Guilty: The Problems with Pretrial Detention

September 17, 2020 by Grayson Pope

Our pretrial system favors those with money. That needs to change.

The Problems with Pretrial Detention

On any given day, roughly 476,000 citizens are incarcerated in our nation's jails prior to any trial or conviction. These men and women now comprise about 65% of the jail population and nearly a quarter of our nation's incarcerated population.

When an individual is arrested and charged with a crime, a hearing takes place where a judicial official weighs the person's risk of flight or danger to the community. A judge can decide to hold the person until trial or impose conditions for pretrial release, such as a bail. That bail often includes a deposit to ensure the person comes to their court date without violating their conditions of release.

In American law, these financial requirements for release were seen as a way to provide strong incentives for people to behave responsibly in the community before court appearances. Advocates for justice have long feared that hefty bail amounts can unjustly burden the poor. That's why James Madison wrote a prohibition against "excessive bail" into our Bill of Rights.

While the Constitution prohibits excessive bail and guarantees the right to a speedy trial, it does not define a set time limit for pretrial detention. Many people are unable to post the amount of money required for their release before trial, or they waive that right in hopes of getting a better plea bargain. The time an individual spends in detention prior to trial varies by jurisdiction from weeks to months. The median wait from arrest to adjudication for detained felony defendants is 68 days, but many are kept far longer, with some waiting years to have their day in court.

Our current system for determining pretrial detention should unsettle all American citizens. It stands in the way of just process, disproportionately burdens the poor, and perpetuates crime.

'Do not pervert justice; do not show partiality to the poor or favoritism to the great, but judge your neighbor fairly.'
- Leviticus 19:15

THE PROBLEMS WITH PRETRIAL DETENTION

The justice system is not always just, especially for the poorest among us. The ability to pay money bail—not whether someone poses a serious risk to society—significantly impacts why most pretrial detainees remain in custody today. Two people accused of committing the same crime may receive different outcomes based on wealth. One stays in jail pending trial, the other is released solely because he has bond money.

If how much cash you have is the only factor determining your freedom, then the criminal justice system is unjust. It favors the rich at the expense of the poor. This is contrary to the witness of Scripture. Pretrial justice should matter to Christians because justice matters to our Lord. Leviticus 19:15 says, "Do not pervert justice; do not show partiality to the poor or favoritism to the great, but judge your neighbor fairly" (NIV).

In addition to disproportionately burdening the poor, excessive reliance on pretrial detention also contributes to more crime. One study concluded that "the pretrial detention of 10,000 people charged with misdemeanors could be expected to result in 400 additional felonies and 600 more misdemeanors than if they had been released pretrial." That’s because a pretrial detention can lead to the following in the lives of those held in pretrial detention:

  • Unemployment.
  • Spiraling into addiction.
  • The unraveling of family relationships.
  • Sustained contact with peers who more extensive criminal histories.
Prison Fellowship recommends lawmakers explore the wider use and continued improvement of pretrial risk assessment, building upon earlier reforms in New Jersey and county governments in Iowa, North Carolina, South Dakota, and elsewhere.

A BETTER WAY FORWARD

Courts should only use pretrial detention when there is objective evidence that someone poses an immediate risk of harm to public safety or a strong risk of not returning for their trial. And pretrial conditions of release should be used in the least restrictive and most effective ways possible to advance public safety and ensure a person's appearance in court.

Lawmakers should replace our current method of determining pretrial detention through monetary bail with more just approaches that deliver better results. Like risk assessment tools. These tools use a variety of factors to estimate an individual's likelihood of appearing in court without a new arrest and guide judges in assessing whether to order detention or release with or without specific conditions. Risk assessment tools need to be reasonably transparent, open to continued refinement and feedback from outside stake holders, and constantly updated with new criminal justice data. When these measures are in place and applied with fidelity, we believe risk assessment tools have the power to positively transform pretrial practices.

Prison Fellowship® recommends lawmakers explore the wider use and continued improvement of pretrial risk assessment, building upon earlier reforms in New Jersey and county governments in Iowa, North Carolina, South Dakota, and elsewhere. In addition, we suggest that lawmakers experiment with improved forms of pretrial supervision and consider reduced reliance on cash bail.

SUPPORT PRETRIAL REFORM IN YOUR STATE

Tell you governor that you support pretrial justice reforms that put all our citizens on equal footing, regardless of their wealth status.

CONTACT YOUR LAWMAKERS

DID YOU ENJOY THIS ARTICLE?

Make sure you don' t miss out on any of our helpful articles and incredible transformation stories! Sign up to receive our weekly newsletter, and you' ll get great content delivered directly to your inbox.

Your privacy is safe with us. We will never sell, trade, or share your personal information.

Filed Under: Advocacy & Reentry Tagged With: Criminal Justice Reform, Pretrial

SELECT A TOPIC

  • Advocacy & Reentry
  • Angel Tree
  • Families of Prisoners
  • Feature Stories
  • From the CEO
  • Hope Events
  • Inside Journal
  • Press Releases
  • Prison & Prisoners
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Prison Fellowship International
  • Prison Fellowship News & Updates
  • Reentry
  • Second Chance Month
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Warden Exchange

MOST POPULAR

But How Can We Help? Q&A With a Business Leader

April 26, 2023

But How Can We Help? Q&A With A Prison Ministry Pastor

April 19, 2023

Road to Second Chances Prayer Walk 2023

April 12, 2023

LATEST VIDEOS

WATCH ALL VIDEOS

JOIN OUR ONLINE COMMUNITY

FACEBOOK
TWITTER
INSTAGRAM
YOUTUBE
LINKEDIN
PF®
PFM®

RECOMMENDED LINKS

  • Ways to Donate
  • Inspirational Stories
  • Angel Tree Program
  • Prison Fellowship Academy
  • Justice Reform

RESOURCES

  • For Families & Friends of Prisoners
  • For Churches & Angel Tree Volunteers
  • For Media Outlets
  • Warden Exchange

JOIN RESTORATION PARTNERS AND WITNESS GOD RESTORE LIVES

Restoration Partners give monthly to bring life-changing prison ministry programs to incarcerated men and women across the country.

 

JOIN NOW
  • CONTACT US
  • EMPLOYMENT
  • PRIVACY
  • FINANCIALS
© 2023 PRISON FELLOWSHIP®

Angel Tree®, Angel Tree Camping®, Angel Tree Sports ClinicTM, Angel Tree Sports CampsTM, and Warden Exchange® are programs of Prison Fellowship®.